Heresies Archives - Scaturrex

39 John XXIII (5) Occult Heresy is not Cause of Loss of Papacy

Julien Laurent — Tue, 14 Jul 2026 22:47:48 +0000

On the Juridical Impossibility for a Purely Occult Heresy Revealed Post Mortem to Cause the Ipso Facto Loss of an Ecclesiastical Office, Including the Papacy Table of Contents Introduction Certain Theological and Canonical Principles 2.1 The Church Has Jurisdiction Only over the External and Manifest Forum Continuer à lire →

The post 39 John XXIII (5) Occult Heresy is not Cause of Loss of Papacy appeared first on Scaturrex.

16 Heretical Pope Is Presumed to Be Formal Heretic

Julien Laurent — Thu, 02 Jul 2026 14:13:43 +0000

A Heretical Pope Is Presumed to Be Formal Heretic Theological and Canonical Study Table of Contents The Traditional Distinction between Material Heresy and Formal Heresy Invincible Ignorance in the Case of the Simple Faithful The Public Doctor of the Faith: An Objectively Different Situation Moral Doctrine Continuer à lire →

The post 16 Heretical Pope Is Presumed to Be Formal Heretic appeared first on Scaturrex.

31. D.T.C. Confirms: “A Pope Loses His Office Through Public Heresy”

Julien Laurent — Sat, 11 Apr 2026 00:36:19 +0000

Loss of the Papal Office for Heresy according to the Dictionary of Catholic Theology and others. Table of contents 1. Preliminary notes and fundamental principle 1.1. According to the Fathers of the Church 1.2. The 135 authors 2. The doctrine in the Dictionary of Catholic Theology (D.T.C.): controversy on Continuer à lire →

The post 31. D.T.C. Confirms: “A Pope Loses His Office Through Public Heresy” appeared first on Scaturrex.

41 Paul VI Pope Became Antipope

Julien Laurent — Wed, 28 Jan 2026 21:43:47 +0000

The Case of Paul VI Pope Become Antipope Having Become a Formal Heretic He Lost His Office Table of Contents: Introduction 1: Fundamental Definitions and Distinctions 1.1. Definition of Heresy and Its Consequences 1.2. Distinction between Material Heresy and Formal Heresy 1.3. Pertinacity Continuer à lire →

The post 41 Paul VI Pope Became Antipope appeared first on Scaturrex.

38 John XXIII (4) After His Death: Public Accusation of Occult Heresies

Julien Laurent — Mon, 26 Jan 2026 21:50:55 +0000

John XXIII (4) After His Death: Public Accusation of Occult Heresies Table of Contents Introduction The Proofs Advanced of Angelo Roncalli’s Membership in Freemasonry 1.1. Testimony of Carlos Vazquez Rangel, Grand Commander of the Supreme Council of Masons of Mexico 1.2. Testimony of Pier Carpi Continuer à lire →

The post 38 John XXIII (4) After His Death: Public Accusation of Occult Heresies appeared first on Scaturrex.

35 John XXIII (1)Before Election was Semi-Heretical

Julien Laurent — Mon, 26 Jan 2026 20:34:59 +0000

Jean XXIII (Part 1) Mgr Roncalli before his Election was Semi-Heretical Table of Contents: Introduction The Facts 2.1. Influenced by Modernist Ideas since the Year 1914 2.2. Association with a Modernist Bishop 2.3. Acceptance of the Cardinal’s Hat from a Socialist 2.4. A Continuer à lire →

The post 35 John XXIII (1)Before Election was Semi-Heretical appeared first on Scaturrex.

34 Principle of Unity: “Unity in Faith, Liberty in Opinions, Charity in All thing”

Julien Laurent — Mon, 26 Jan 2026 20:22:14 +0000

The Solutions A Principle of Unity: “In fide unitas, in opiniis libertas, in omnibus caritas” (Unity in faith, liberty in opinions, charity in all thing) The instrument par excellence of unity of and in the Church is in practice the papacy. But because we do not have, for a certain—and Continuer à lire →

The post 34 Principle of Unity: “Unity in Faith, Liberty in Opinions, Charity in All thing” appeared first on Scaturrex.

33 Paul VI and his Successors are Heretics

Julien Laurent — Sun, 25 Jan 2026 22:21:39 +0000

Proofs that Paul VI, and his Successors, John Paul I, John Paul II, Benedict XVI, Francis I, Leo XIV… are Heretics Table of Contents Introduction Section 1: Definition of Heresy and its Consequences Section 2: Vatican II Contains Flagrant Heresies Section 3: Paul VI and his Continuer à lire →

The post 33 Paul VI and his Successors are Heretics appeared first on Scaturrex.

30 Opinion 5 is Common Doctrine “Pope Loses Office Ipso facto by public Heresy”

Julien Laurent — Sun, 25 Jan 2026 22:16:10 +0000

FIFTH OPINION IS COMMON DOCTRINE: HAVING FALLEN INTO MANIFEST HERESY, THE POPE LOSES THE PONTIFICATE IPSO FACTO Main Source: The masterful work “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?” by Professor Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira, theologian of Campos, Brazil. Table of contents Introduction: this Continuer à lire →

The post 30 Opinion 5 is Common Doctrine “Pope Loses Office Ipso facto by public Heresy” appeared first on Scaturrex.

29 Wrong Opinion 4 “Heretic Pope Loses Office only After Declaration”

Julien Laurent — Sun, 25 Jan 2026 22:10:10 +0000

Fourth Opinion – The Heretical Pope Loses the Pontificate Only After the Intervention of a Declarative Act of His Heresy Main Source: The masterful work “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?” by Professor Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira, theologian of Campos, Brazil. According to this Continuer à lire →

The post 29 Wrong Opinion 4 “Heretic Pope Loses Office only After Declaration” appeared first on Scaturrex.

28 Wrong Opinion 3 “Heretic Pope Never Loses his Pontificate”

Julien Laurent — Sun, 25 Jan 2026 22:06:51 +0000

Third Opinion: Even If He Falls into Notorious Heresy, the Pope Never Loses the Pontificate Main source: “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira Table of Contents Introduction to the Third Opinion (Bouix) Bouix’s Main Arguments Continuer à lire →

The post 28 Wrong Opinion 3 “Heretic Pope Never Loses his Pontificate” appeared first on Scaturrex.

27 Wrong Opinion 2 “By Internal Heresy, the Pope Loses his Office”

Julien Laurent — Sun, 25 Jan 2026 21:59:54 +0000

Loss of Papacy: ipso facto, by internal heresy Second opinion: In falling into heresy, even simply internal, the Pope loses ipso facto the pontificate Main source: “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira Table of contents Introduction Continuer à lire →

The post 27 Wrong Opinion 2 “By Internal Heresy, the Pope Loses his Office” appeared first on Scaturrex.