Crisis in the Church Archives - Scaturrex

34 Date of Loss of the Pontificate (1964)

Julien Laurent — Wed, 14 Oct 2026 22:38:00 +0000

Date of the first heresy of a pope Of the heretical proposition promulgated on 21 November 1964 Table of contents Terms of the thesis The major: the dogma The minor: the promulgated propositions The contradiction Objections and responses 5.1 Objection 1: the Council Continuer à lire →

The post 34 Date of Loss of the Pontificate (1964) appeared first on Scaturrex.

33 Documentary Chronology of the First Sedevacantist Reactions

Julien Laurent — Wed, 30 Sep 2026 01:36:47 +0000

Documentary Chronology of the First Sedevacantist Reactions Research on the First Reactions to the Crisis of Pontifical Authority (1958–1973) Table of contents Purpose and delimitation Background: from the death of Pius XII to Vatican II 1962 – Il Complotto contro la Chiesa and the Mexican milieu 1965 Continuer à lire →

The post 33 Documentary Chronology of the First Sedevacantist Reactions appeared first on Scaturrex.

# SSPX is Unacceptable

Julien Laurent — Fri, 24 Jul 2026 12:25:13 +0000

Why the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X and its positions are unacceptable Table of contents Introduction The Catholic doctrine before 1964 on public heresy and the loss of office The recognition of the occupants of the See of Peter by the FSSPX The practice of Continuer à lire →

The post # SSPX is Unacceptable appeared first on Scaturrex.

04 Territorial Exercise of the Jurisdiction of Bishops without Pope

Julien Laurent — Thu, 23 Jul 2026 16:38:07 +0000

The territorial exercise of the jurisdiction of Catholic bishops in a time of prolonged vacancy of the Apostolic See Table of contents Introduction Conciliar and canonical foundations Teachings of the classical theologians The apostolic model and the nature of territorial right The supply of jurisdiction Concrete application and conclusion Continuer à lire →

The post 04 Territorial Exercise of the Jurisdiction of Bishops without Pope appeared first on Scaturrex.

42 Prolonged Vacancy of See Does Not Interrupt Its Succession

Julien Laurent — Wed, 15 Jul 2026 22:36:22 +0000

The Prolonged Vacancy of the Apostolic See Does Not Interrupt Its Promised Succession. Table of Contents Introduction. 1: Status quaestionis. 2: The Distinction between the Permanent Institution and the Current Exercise of the Primacy. 3: The Argument of Prescription. 4: The Historical Vacancies of the Continuer à lire →

The post 42 Prolonged Vacancy of See Does Not Interrupt Its Succession appeared first on Scaturrex.

40 Paul VI and Vatican II Did Not Use Infallibility

Julien Laurent — Wed, 15 Jul 2026 00:58:44 +0000

Paul VI Did Not Use Infallibility During the Council neither After Table of Contents Introduction The Declarations Relating to the Second Vatican Council 1.1 The Official Notification of November 16, 1964 1.2 The General Audience of January 12, 1966 1.3 The General Audience of September 21, 1966 The Declarations Continuer à lire →

The post 40 Paul VI and Vatican II Did Not Use Infallibility appeared first on Scaturrex.

16 Heretical Pope Is Presumed to Be Formal Heretic

Julien Laurent — Thu, 02 Jul 2026 14:13:43 +0000

A Heretical Pope Is Presumed to Be a Formal Heretic Theological and Canonical Study Table of contents The traditional distinction between material heresy and formal heresy Invincible ignorance in the simple faithful The public doctor of the faith: an objectively different situation Moral doctrine on the species of ignorance Bellarmine Continuer à lire →

The post 16 Heretical Pope Is Presumed to Be Formal Heretic appeared first on Scaturrex.

13 Episcopal Consecrations during a Vacancy of the See

Julien Laurent — Sun, 28 Jun 2026 21:38:40 +0000

Episcopal Consecrations during a vacancy of the Apostolic See: a historical precedent and the question of extraordinary jurisdiction Table of contents The historical precedent of the interregnum of 1268-1271 The patristic precedents invoked by Catholic theology The tacit communication of episcopal jurisdiction The right Continuer à lire →

The post 13 Episcopal Consecrations during a Vacancy of the See appeared first on Scaturrex.

11 Indefectibility of Government of Church (by future Pope Gregory XVI)

Julien Laurent — Fri, 26 Jun 2026 15:25:56 +0000

The Indefectibility and Immutability of the Government of the Church According to Dom Mauro Cappellari (future Pope Gregory XVI) Table of contents Introduction 1.1. Historical context of the Treatise 1.2. Place in The Triumph of the Holy See 1.3. Doctrinal and polemical object Continuer à lire →

The post 11 Indefectibility of Government of Church (by future Pope Gregory XVI) appeared first on Scaturrex.

The 1968 Rite of Episcopal Consecration is invalid

Julien Laurent — Mon, 13 Apr 2026 14:34:50 +0000

The 1968 Rite of Episcopal Consecration: Return to Patristic Sources or Rupture with the Roman Tradition? A Theological and Liturgical Analysis of the Claimed Derivation from St. Hippolytus’ Apostolic Tradition Table of Contents Introduction: The Context of the Controversy The Claimed “Direct Derivation” from the Apostolic Tradition of Continuer à lire →

The post The 1968 Rite of Episcopal Consecration is invalid appeared first on Scaturrex.

31. Heresy causes Loss of Office – List of Authors

Julien Laurent — Sat, 11 Apr 2026 00:36:19 +0000

Public Heresy and Loss of the Pontifical Office The thesis of Bellarmine, its foundations, its conditions and its reception among theologians and canonists. The D.T.C. ( Dictionnaire de théologie catholique ) and the testimonies of theological tradition Table of contents 1 Object and articulation of the demonstration 1.1 The Continuer à lire →

The post 31. Heresy causes Loss of Office – List of Authors appeared first on Scaturrex.

The Siri Thesis: For and Against

Julien Laurent — Mon, 30 Mar 2026 14:03:19 +0000

An Objective Historical, Canonical, and Theological Presentation of the Arguments Concerning the Alleged Election of Cardinal Giuseppe Siri as Pope Gregory XVII in the Conclaves of 1958 and 1963 Table of Contents Introduction Chapter 1 – Arguments in Favor of the Siri Thesis Chapter 2 – Continuer à lire →

The post The Siri Thesis: For and Against appeared first on Scaturrex.