Sainte, Catholique, Apostolique, Traditionnelle, Une, Romaine, Reine, Eglise, Xti du Christ † Tradition † Sede Vacante
The 1968 Rite of Episcopal Consecration: Return to Patristic Sources or Rupture with the Roman Tradition? A Theological and Liturgical Analysis of the Claimed Derivation from St. Hippolytus’ Apostolic Tradition Table of Contents Introduction: The Context of the Controversy The Claimed “Direct Derivation” from the Apostolic Tradition of Continuer à lire →
Public Heresy and Loss of the Pontifical Office The thesis of Bellarmine, its foundations, its conditions and its reception among theologians and canonists. The D.T.C. ( Dictionnaire de théologie catholique ) and the testimonies of theological tradition Table of contents 1 Object and articulation of the demonstration 1.1 The Continuer à lire →
An Objective Historical, Canonical, and Theological Presentation of the Arguments Concerning the Alleged Election of Cardinal Giuseppe Siri as Pope Gregory XVII in the Conclaves of 1958 and 1963 Table of Contents Introduction Chapter 1 – Arguments in Favor of the Siri Thesis Chapter 2 – Continuer à lire →
I was asked the question about the validity of baptism conferred by heretics and schismatics, like the conciliar ones of Vatican II. First, let’s look at baptism by all heretics and schismatics, then we will consider the situation in the conciliar sect of Vatican II. I. Baptism Conferred by a Continuer à lire →
The Right of Conclave by the College of Bishops In an Imperfect General Council (I.G.C.) Table of Contents Introduction I. Doctrinal Foundations of Hierarchical Continuity and Papal Election a) Powers of the College of Bishops in the Absence of Papal Authority b) Infallibility of the Unanimous College Continuer à lire →
General Conclusion “The Catholic Church resembles a spring: the more one pushes it down, the more it springs back with vigour” (P.L.) The Catholic Church, founded by Our Lord Jesus Christ as a visible and perfect society, necessarily subsists until the end of time, indefectible in its hierarchical constitution Continuer à lire →
Lay Simony on Indolent Clergy Problem of laymen exerting undue influence by their financial contributions, governing in fact certain indolent priests, in contempt of episcopal authority. Table of Contents Introduction The State of the question Definition of the problem according to traditional Catholic doctrine Millenary historical roots Current Continuer à lire →
Hierarchical Submission Moral Necessity of Hierarchical Submission in the Catholic Church in Times of Prolonged Vacancy of the Apostolic See Table of Contents: I. Introduction II. Doctrinal Foundations of Hierarchical Submission III. Moral Duty of the Faithful: Submission to a True Catholic Priest IV. Moral Duty of Priests: Submission to Continuer à lire →
The Valid and Licit Missals in these times of prolonged sedevacantism Who decides to use which missal and with which jurisdiction? Table of Contents: Concern for Unity Unity Remains However… the reforms The Liturgical Reforms under Pius XII and the Imposed Missals The Imposition of the Missal of 1962 Continuer à lire →
The Jurisdiction of Suppliance during a Period of Prolonged Vacancy of the Apostolic See Table of contents: Introduction – Definition and importance of the jurisdiction of suppliance. – Context of the prolonged vacancy and promise of Christ. Doctrinal Foundations – The Church as a perfect and indefectible society. Continuer à lire →
Doctrine of the Indefectibility of the Catholic Church Table of Contents Introduction Definition of Indefectibility Scriptural and Traditional Foundations 3.1 Scriptural Foundations 3.2 Traditional Foundations Aspects of Indefectibility Continuity of Ecclesiastical Authority in Times of Crisis 5.1 Principle of Devolution, Supplying Jurisdiction and Role of Faithful Bishops 5.2 Survival Continuer à lire →
The Case of Paul VI Pope Become Antipope Having Become a Formal Heretic He Lost His Office Table of Contents: Introduction 1: Fundamental Definitions and Distinctions 1.1. Definition of Heresy and Its Consequences 1.2. Distinction between Material Heresy and Formal Heresy 1.3. Pertinacity Continuer à lire →
The Bull Cum ex Apostolatus Officio of Paul IV and the Universal Peaceful Acceptance of a Pope Reconciliation with the Dogmatic Fact and the Infallibility of the Church Table of Contents Introduction The Doctrine of the Universal and Peaceful Acceptance of a Pope The Bull Cum ex Apostolatus Officio of Continuer à lire →
John XXIII (4) After His Death: Public Accusation of Occult Heresies Table of Contents Introduction The Proofs Advanced of Angelo Roncalli’s Membership in Freemasonry 1.1. Testimony of Carlos Vazquez Rangel, Grand Commander of the Supreme Council of Masons of Mexico 1.2. Testimony of Pier Carpi Continuer à lire →
Jean XXIII (3) Semi-Heretic Pope Errors after His Election until His Death Table of Contents: Introduction Universal Acceptance of the Papacy of John XXIII from the Conclave until 1971 2.1. The 1958 Conclave and the Immediate Acceptance 2.2. Absence of Organized Opposition before the Continuer à lire →
Jean XXIII Pope (2) His Election and Universal Peaceful Acceptance (U.P.A.) Table of contents Preliminaries Plan for examining the papacy of John XXIII Introduction Certain principle of theology and canon law Certain historical facts 4.1. Election of 28 October 1958 4.2. Immediate and Continuer à lire →
Jean XXIII (Part 1) Mgr Roncalli before his Election was Semi-Heretical Table of Contents: Introduction The Facts 2.1. Influenced by Modernist Ideas since the Year 1914 2.2. Association with a Modernist Bishop 2.3. Acceptance of the Cardinal’s Hat from a Socialist 2.4. A Continuer à lire →
The Solutions A Principle of Unity: “In fide unitas, in opinionibus libertas, in omnibus caritas” (Unity in faith, liberty in opinions, charity in all thing) The instrument par excellence of unity of and in the Church is in practice the papacy. But because we do not have, for a certain—and Continuer à lire →
Proofs that Paul VI and his Successors (till today 29/9/2026), John Paul I, John Paul II, Benedict XVI, Francis I and Leo XIV are Heretics Table of contents Introduction Section 1: Definition of Heresy and its Consequences Section 2: Vatican II Contains Flagant Heresies Section Continuer à lire →
FIFTH OPINION IS COMMON DOCTRINE: FALLEN INTO MANIFEST HERESY, THE POPE LOSES IPSO FACTO THE PONTIFICATE Main Source: The magisterial work “The New Mass of Paul VI: What to Think of It?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira, theologian of Campos, Brazil. Table of contents Introduction: Continuer à lire →
Fourth Opinion – The Heretical Pope Does Not Effectively Lose the Pontificate Until After the Intervention of a Declaratory Act of His Heresy Principal source: The masterly work “The New Mass of Paul VI: What Should One Think of It?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira, theologian of Continuer à lire →
Third Opinion: Even If He Falls into Notorious Heresy, the Pope Never Loses the Pontificate Main source: “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira Table of Contents Introduction to the Third Opinion (Bouix) Bouix’s Main Arguments Continuer à lire →
Loss of the Papacy: ipso facto, by internal heresy Second opinion: By falling into heresy, even merely internal heresy, the Pope loses the pontificate ipso facto Principal source: The masterly work “The New Mass of Paul VI: What Should One Think of It?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Continuer à lire →
It is “impossible” that a Pope become a heretic First opinion: God will never permit the Pope to fall into heresy Main source: “The New Mass of Paul VI: What to Think of It?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira Table of contents Introduction Arguments Continuer à lire →
The Theological Hypothesis of a Heretical Pope Following Saint Bellarmine, as Did the First Vatican Council (1870) Main source: The masterly work ‘La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?’ by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira, a theologian from Campos, Brazil (Chiré-en-Montreuil, Diffusion de la Pensée Française, Continuer à lire →
Vatican II Lists of Heresies and Errors Introduction The theological notes or qualifications of the Church List of heresies of Vatican II 3.1. The civil right to “religious liberty” 3.2. “Revelation was completed at the Crucifixion” 3.3. Heretical and schismatic sects are “means of salvation” 3.4. “Public common prayer with Continuer à lire →
Vatican II is Apostate: Nostra Aetate and the Spirit of Assisi Table of Contents Introduction Theological Definition of Apostasy Proof that the Erroneous Proposition Comes from Nostra Aetate 3.1. Text of Nostra Aetate paragraph 2 3.2. On Buddhism (Nostra Aetate paragraph 2) 3.3. On Hinduism (Nostra Aetate paragraph 2) 3.4. Continuer à lire →
Major Heresy of the “Council” Vatican II: “Dignitatis Humanae” in contradiction with the dogma of the Social Kingship of Christ Table of Contents Introduction Religious liberty as a universal right 2.1 Presentation of the text of Dignitatis Humanae 2.2 Proofs drawn from the Magisterium 2.3 Contradiction clearly established and Continuer à lire →
Major Heresy of Vatican II: “Gaudium et Spes” The Constitution “Gaudium et Spes” is contradictory to the Infallible Teaching of “Quanta Cura” and of the “Syllabus Errorum” Table of contents Introduction Section 1 : The Infallibility of “Quanta Cura” and of the “Syllabus Errorum” Section Continuer à lire →
Tacit resignation of an ecclesiastical office by public defection from the faith according to canon 188, n. 4 of the 1917 Code Application to Paul VI’s loss of the papacy Table of contents Introduction The general concepts of tacit resignation according to canon 188 Argument Continuer à lire →