John Paul I was an antipope

John Paul I was an antipope

 

 

Table of contents

 

  1. Object and limit of this survey

 

  1. The thesis of the public law of the Church would have been false

 

  1. An accommodation of artificial contraception would be possible

 

  1. The Talmud would help to understand the Gospel

 

  1. A Protestant baptized outside the Church would be a fervent Christian in the proper sense

 

  1. God would be our mother even more than our Father

 

  1. Public praise of a satanist and anticatholic poet

 

  1. The sin of the flesh would perhaps be the least of sins

 

  1. Ruptures with the papal tradition, outside defined heresy

 

  1. Limit and conclusion

 

List of sources

 

 

 

  1. Object and limit of this survey

 

Here are the points that the page of Novus Ordo Watch, The Facts about “Pope” John Paul I, and an article from the same site advance against Albino Luciani, outside of the simple global acceptance of Vatican II.

 

  1. The thesis of the public law of the Church would have been false

 

Erroneous sentence. Luciani said, according to the biography below: “The thesis I found hardest to live with was the one on religious freedom. For years I had taught the public law theses of Cardinal Ottaviani, according to which only the truth had rights. In the end, I convinced myself we had been wrong.” Translation: “The thesis with which I had the most difficulty living was that of religious freedom. For years I had taught the public law theses of Cardinal Ottaviani, according to which only the truth has rights. In the end, I convinced myself that we had been wrong.”

 

Reference: Charles Moritz and others, editors, Current Biography Yearbook 1978, The H. W. Wilson Company, New York, 1979, article “John Paul I, Pope”, p. 210. Original language: English.

 

Contradicted doctrine. Only the true religion has, by divine right, the right to be publicly professed. The Catholic State must recognize it and not grant an equal right to false cults. Pius IX, encyclical Quanta cura, 8 December 1864, and Syllabus, proposition 77: “In our time it is no longer useful that the Catholic religion be held as the only religion of the State, to the exclusion of all other cults.” Condemned proposition. Leo XIII, encyclical Libertas, 20 June 1888, and Immortale Dei, 1 November 1885, teach that the liberty of cults, understood as a right, is contrary to the doctrine. The Vatican I council did not reverse that. Conclusion: to renounce the thesis of Ottaviani on this point is to renounce the prior magisterium. This is certain as doctrinal opposition.

 

  1. An accommodation of artificial contraception would be possible

 

Erroneous sentence. Mgr Luciani advised Paul VI in 1965 to relax the restrictions on contraceptives, and that he had personally concluded that an accommodation of artificial contraception could be made within the teaching of the Church, and that he wrote it to the pope. The cited biography says: “Luciani personally concluded that some accommodation for artificial birth control could be made within the teachings of the church, and he wrote to the Pope to that effect.” Translation: “Luciani personally concluded that a certain accommodation for artificial birth control could be made within the teaching of the Church, and he wrote to the pope in that sense.”

 

Reference: same Current Biography Yearbook 1978, p. 210, and the article of La Stampa, Vatican Insider, 13 June 2018, “Luciani and the Triveneto bishops, that openness on the pill”.

 

La Stampa reports the conclusion of the Triveneto dossier, drafted by Luciani and made its own by those bishops: “Non consta, è dubbio. Nel dubbio, non si può accusare di peccato chi usa la pillola.” Translation: “It does not appear, it is doubtful. In doubt, one cannot accuse of sin the one who uses the pill.” This is certain as text reported by La Stampa in 2018.

 

Contradicted doctrine. Pius XI, encyclical Casti connubii, 31 December 1930, declares intrinsically evil every use of marriage where the act is deliberately deprived of its natural power to procreate, and says that no reason, even very grave, can make that what is intrinsically against nature become conform to nature and morally good. The Holy Office, decree of 21 May 1851 and subsequent responses, and the common moral theology before 1962, hold conjugal onanism as a mortal sin by its nature, without lightness of matter. Necessary conclusion: to say that the use of the contraceptive pill cannot be accused of sin, or that an accommodation is possible in the doctrine, contradicts Casti connubii. This is certain.

 

  1. The Talmud would help to understand the Gospel

 

Erroneous sentence. In a sermon of 1976, Luciani would have denounced the Talmud as “full of fables and childish and bizarre things”, translation: “full of fables and childish and bizarre things”, while holding that this work “can help us in understanding the Gospel at certain points”, translation: “can help us to understand the Gospel at certain points”. Reference: Lori Pieper, editor, A Passionate Adventure: Living the Catholic Faith Today, Tau Cross Books, Bronx, New York, 2013, Kindle locations 2462 and 4564. Language: English.

 

Read also according to I. B. Pranaitis, The Talmud Unmasked, p. 30, the Talmudic blasphemies against Our Lord.

 

Contradicted doctrine. The Church condemned the Talmud for its blasphemies against Christ and His Mother, and ordered its censorship or destruction. Gregory IX, letters of 1239. Pius V and the prior popes maintained the prohibition of non-expurgated editions. Saint Paul forbids Jewish fables: “not to give heed to Jewish fables” (Titus 1, 14). Translation according to the Vulgate. To seek in the Talmud an aid to understand the Gospel, after having recognized the fables, contradicts this condemnation and this defense. This is certain as to the condemnation of the blasphemous Talmud.

 

  1. A Protestant baptized outside the Church would be a fervent Christian in the proper sense

 

Erroneous sentence. In September 1978, at the Angelus, Luciani called President James Carter, Baptist, a “fervent Christian”, translation: “fervent Christian”. The published Vatican text confirms it. Angelus of 10 September 1978, official French text: the passage on Carter is in the Spanish version of the same day, “El Presidente Carter, que es cristiano fervoroso”. Translation: “President Carter, who is a fervent Christian”. Reference: Vatican site, Angelus, 10 September 1978.

 

Contradicted doctrine. Outside the Catholic Church there is no salvation, and the separated sects are not the Church of Christ. Pius IX, Syllabus, proposition 18, condemns the idea that Protestantism is only another form of the same true religion. Leo XIII, Satis cognitum, 29 June 1896, teaches that one cannot hold as a member of the body of Christ him who is separated from the unity of faith and of government. Pius XI, Mortalium animos, 6 January 1928, refuses to hold the dissidents as members of the Church of Christ in the same title. One can say that a validly baptized person has the baptismal character. One cannot call him a fervent Christian as if he were in the true faith. Conclusion: the expression, without correction, favors indifferentism. This is certain as doctrine.

 

  1. God would be our mother even more than our Father

 

Erroneous sentence. Angelus of 10 September 1978, official French text of the Vatican: “Il est papa ; plus encore Il est mère.” Italian: “E’ papà; più ancora è madre.” Translation: “He is our father; even more he is our mother.” Reference: Novus Ordo Watch, cited page, and vatican.va, Angelus of 10 September 1978. This is certain.

 

Contradicted doctrine. The first Person revealed Himself as Father, not as Mother. Our Lord teaches: “You therefore pray thus: Our Father who art in heaven” (Matthew 6, 9). The Symbol of Nicaea-Constantinople: “I believe in one God, the Father almighty”. The council of Lateran IV, 1215, confessed the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Isaiah 49, 15 and Matthew 23, 37 compare the divine solicitude to that of a mother. They do not say that God is mother, nor that he is so more than he is Father. This is a correct distinction.

 

Conclusion: the phrase exceeds the scriptural comparison and contradicts the revealed name. This is certain as doctrinal deviation.

 

  1. Public praise of a satanist and anticatholic poet

 

Erroneous sentence. Angelus of 17 September 1978. Luciani praises Giosuè Carducci, professor at Bologna, for his devotion to the pupils, and gives him as an example of a high idea of teaching. Reference: Novus Ordo Watch, cited page, Angelus of 17 September 1978. The site affirms that Carducci was anticlerical and author of an “Inno a Satana”, Hymn to Satan, and that he called the priests “the true and constant enemies of Italy”. It refers for the proofs to a blog, Call Me Jorge, 2015. The existence of the Hymn to Satan of Carducci, 1863, is a known literary fact. I have not re-verified here the exact verse on the priests. Therefore: the praise is certain. The satanist character of the poem is certain as to the title and the object.

 

Contradicted doctrine. “What agreement has justice with iniquity? What union has light with darkness? What concord has Christ with Belial?” (2 Corinthians 6, 14-15). Translation according to the sense of the Vulgate. The fourth commandment of the Church and the divine law forbid scandal and communion with the works of darkness (Ephesians 5, 11). To praise publicly, without any reserve on the apostasy and the hymn to Satan, a public enemy of the Church, contradicts this precept. This is not by itself a defined heretical proposition. It is a scandal against the faith. Perhaps this is the most grave deviation of Luciani.

 

  1. The sin of the flesh would perhaps be the least of sins

 

See the site Novus Ordo Watch, article of 14 February 2019, Moral Advice from “Pope” Francis. This article informs us that this erroneous conception of the antipope Francis had already been advocated before by Mgr Luciani.

 

Erroneous sentence.

 

In his function as Novus Ordo patriarch of Venice, the then “cardinal” Albino Luciani (later “pope” John Paul I) said to people in effect roughly the same error as later antipope Francis. A testimony in this sense was given by Abbé Mario Senigaglia, secretary of Luciani in Venice, who declared to the author David Yallop: “He [Luciani] was a very understanding man. Very often I heard him say to couples: ‘We have made sex the only sin, whereas in reality it is linked to human weakness and fragility and it is therefore perhaps the least of sins.’” (David A. Yallop, In God’s Name: An Investigation into the Murder of Pope John Paul I [New York, NY: Carroll & Graf Publishers, 2007], p. 44).

 

Contradicted doctrine. The sins against purity that are consummated are mortal by their nature and do not admit lightness of matter. Council of Trent, session 14, and common moral theology, for example Saint Alphonsus de Liguori, Theologia moralis, on the sixth commandment. Our Lord: “Whoever looks at a woman to lust after her has already committed adultery with her in his heart” (Matthew 5, 28). Let us think of the word attributed to Jacinta of Fatima: more souls go to hell for the sins of the flesh than for any other reason.

 

Conclusion: to call this sin the least because it comes from weakness is false and dangerous.

 

  1. Ruptures with the papal tradition, outside defined heresy

 

Outside doctrine, the site adds three facts of rupture with the papal tradition, not heresies: suppression of the solemn coronation in favor of a simple installation; abandonment then constrained resumption of the sedia gestatoria; choice of the double name John-Paul to honor John XXIII and Paul VI, with the numeral I from the first day. Reference: the same page.

 

  1. Limit and conclusion

 

Novus Ordo Watch proves public words and acts opposed to the doctrine or to the tradition prior to 1964. According to the rule that the Church imposes on us, the last pope was Paul VI until the fall into heresy in 1964. Luciani, elected in 1978 by the sect issued from this rupture, was therefore not pope. This conclusion follows from this premise and from the facts above.

 

List of sources

 

  1. Novus Ordo Watch, The Facts about “Pope” John Paul I, page https://novusordowatch.org/john-paul-i/. Language: English. Secondary source of the citations and of the account of the acts of September 1978.

 

  1. Novus Ordo Watch, Moral Advice from “Pope” Francis, 14 February 2019. Language: English. Article that attaches to Luciani the statement on the sin of the flesh.

 

  1. Charles Moritz and others, editors, Current Biography Yearbook 1978, The H. W. Wilson Company, New York, 1979, article “John Paul I, Pope”, p. 210. Original language: English. Printed volume not re-verified here.

 

  1. La Stampa, Vatican Insider, 13 June 2018, “Luciani and the Triveneto bishops, that openness on the pill”. Language of the cited article: English in the referral of the site; the conclusion of the Triveneto dossier is given in Italian. The site does not reproduce the autograph letter.

 

  1. Lori Pieper, editor, A Passionate Adventure: Living the Catholic Faith Today, Tau Cross Books, Bronx, New York, 2013, Kindle locations 2462 and 4564. Language: English. Book not consulted here.

 

  1. I. B. Pranaitis, The Talmud Unmasked, p. 30, according to the pagination given by the site. Not re-verified here on the printed edition.

 

  1. Vatican site, vatican.va, Angelus of 10 September 1978, French, Italian, English and Spanish texts. Angelus of 17 September 1978, English and Italian texts.

 

  1. Call Me Jorge, blog, 2015, referred by the site for the proofs on Carducci. The exact verse on the priests has not been re-verified in this response.

 

  1. Giosuè Carducci, Inno a Satana, Hymn to Satan, 1863. Known literary fact as to the title and the object.

 

  1. David A. Yallop, In God’s Name: An Investigation into the Murder of Pope John Paul I, Carroll and Graf, New York, 2007, p. 44. Language: English. Indirect testimony of don Mario Senigaglia, not a text signed by Luciani.

 

  1. Pius IX, encyclical Quanta cura, 8 December 1864, and Syllabus, propositions 18 and 77.

 

  1. Leo XIII, encyclical Immortale Dei, 1 November 1885; encyclical Libertas, 20 June 1888; encyclical Satis cognitum, 29 June 1896.

 

  1. Pius XI, encyclical Mortalium animos, 6 January 1928; encyclical Casti connubii, 31 December 1930.

 

  1. Holy Office, decree of 21 May 1851 and subsequent responses, on conjugal onanism.

 

  1. Gregory IX, letters of 1239, on the Talmud. Pius V and the prior popes, prohibition of non-expurgated editions.

 

  1. Vatican I council, which did not reverse the prior doctrine on the liberty of cults. Council of Lateran IV, 1215. Council of Trent, session 14. Symbol of Nicaea-Constantinople.

 

  1. Saint Alphonsus de Liguori, Theologia moralis, on the sixth commandment. Language: Latin.

 

  1. Holy Scripture according to the Vulgate: Titus 1, 14; Matthew 6, 9; Isaiah 49, 15; Matthew 23, 37; 2 Corinthians 6, 14-15; Ephesians 5, 11; Matthew 5, 28.

 

  1. Word attributed to Jacinta of Fatima, recalled by the site, and which is not a magisterial document.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*