27 Wrong Opinion 2 “By Internal Heresy, the Pope Loses his Office”

Loss of Papacy: ipso facto, by internal heresy Second opinion: In falling into heresy, even simply internal, the Pope loses ipso facto the pontificate   Main source: “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?”  by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira   Table of contents   Introduction Continuer à lire →

26 Wrong Opinion 1 “Pope cannot fall in heresy”

“It is impossible for a Pope to become a heretic” First opinion: God will never permit the Pope to fall into heresy Main source: “La Nouvelle Messe de Paul VI : qu’en penser ?” by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira   Table of contents     Introduction   Arguments Continuer à lire →

25 Heretical Pope acc. to St Bellarmine, Vatican I and Prof da Silveira

The Theological Hypothesis of a Heretical Pope Following Saint Bellarmine, as Vatican I (1870) Source: The magisterial work « The New Mass of Paul VI: What to Make of It? » by Prof. Arnaldo Vidigal Xavier da Silveira, theologian of Campos, Brazil.   Table of contents   Preface      1.1. Continuer à lire →

24 Vatican II – Lists of Heresies and Errors

Vatican II Lists of Heresies and Errors   Introduction     The theological notes or qualifications of the Church   List of heresies of Vatican II    2.1. The civil right to “religious liberty”    2.2. “Revelation was completed at the Crucifixion”    2.3. Heretical and schismatic sects are “means Continuer à lire →

23 Vatican II’s “Nostra Aetate” & the “Spirit of Assisi” are Apostate

Vatican II is Apostate: “Nostra Aetate” and the “Spirit of Assisi”   Table of Contents   Introduction   Theological Definition of Apostasy   Proof that the Erroneous Proposition Comes from Nostra Aetate      3.1. Text of Nostra Aetate paragraph 2      3.2. On Buddhism (Nostra Aetate paragraph 2)      3.3. On Continuer à lire →

22 Heresy of Vatican II : “Dignitatis Humanae”

Major Heresy of the “Council” Vatican II: “Dignitatis Humanae” in Contradiction with the Dogma of the Social Kingship of Christ     Table of Contents     Introduction   Religious Liberty as a Universal Right      2.1 Presentation of the Text of Dignitatis Humanae      2.2 Proofs Drawn from the Continuer à lire →

21 Major Heresy of Vatican II: “Gaudium et Spes”

Major Heresy of Vatican II: “Gaudium et Spes” The Constitution “Gaudium et Spes” is contrary to the Infallible Teaching of “Quanta Cura” and the “Syllabus Errorum”   Table of Contents   Introduction – Section 1: The Infallibility of “Quanta Cura” and the “Syllabus Errorum” – Section 2: The Specific Contradictions Continuer à lire →

20 Tacit Resignation of the Office causes loss of Papacy

The Tacit Renunciation of an Ecclesiastical Office by Public Defection from the Faith according to Canon 188, Nr 4 of the 1917 Code. Application to the Loss of the Papacy of Paul VI   Table of Contents   Introduction   The General Concepts of Tacit Renunciation according to Canon 188   Argument Continuer à lire →

19 Six Causes of Loss of Papacy

The Six Causes of Loss of the Supreme Pontificate according to Canon Law and Scholastic Theology   Table of Contents   Introduction Death Abdication    2.1. Free    2.2. Without Necessary Acceptance Insanity    3.1. Indeed, Natural Reason Requires It    3.2. In the Church, This Truth Is Confirmed Public Heresy Public Apostasy Public Continuer à lire →

17 Apostasy

Apostasy     Table of Contents   Theological and Canonical Definition of Apostasy   Distinction between Apostasy, Heresy and Schism   Essential Characteristics of Apostasy   Causes and Forms of Apostasy   Traditional Canonical Sanctions   Duties towards the Apostate     Conclusion   Note       Theological and Continuer à lire →

15 Heresy and Heretic

Heresy and Heretic A Complete Theological, Canonical, Scriptural, and Historical Study     Table of Contents       Introduction   Definition of Heresy   Definition of the Heretic   Distinctions       4.1. Formal/Material Distinction           4.1.1. Formal Heretic           4.1.2. Material Heretic               4.1.2.1. Common Opinion: They Are Separated from the Church Continuer à lire →

05 The Universal Peaceful Acceptance gives certainty of election

The Peaceful Universal Acceptance Sign of Certitude of Election Table of Contents : Introduction 1.Primary and Original Link with the Sovereign Pontiff 1.1 Thomistic Foundation 1.2 Explicit Doctrine of the Authors 1.3 Radical Healing of Any Prior Occult Vice by the UPA 2. Analogical Extension to Other Ecclesiastical Realities 3. Essential Continuer à lire →

Sacraments received from excommunicated persons

Code of Canon Law CIC 1917 Can. 2260 “§1. The excommunicated shall be prohibited from producing and administering the sacraments and sacraments, with the following exceptions. “§2. The faithful may, subject to paragraph 3, ask an excommunicate for the sacraments and sacramentals for any valid reason, especially when the other Continuer à lire →

Heretical writing of Francis “Fiducia Supplicans” on December 18, 2023 

Since the December 18, 2023 publication of  Fiducia Supplicans, the “Recognize and Resistors” (R&R) as well as Vatican II sect apologists, have been doing incredible feats of mental gymnastics to avoid the inescapable conclusion of sedevacantism. Fiducia Supplicans (FS) allows Vatican II sect “priests” to “bless” couples who are not married according to Church Continuer à lire →

Can a public heretic retain the papacy? As for the case of Paul VI?

The number and the weight of the theological authorities support the contention that a pope who committed a public and notorious act of heresy would automatically cease to be pope. The authors tell us that it is the “most common” teaching of the canonists and theologians; three doctors of the Continuer à lire →

Addition of the name of Saint Joseph in the Canon is authorized

Some historical reference about the insertion of Saint Joseph in the missal. Saint Pius X agreed? We found in the years 1993 that Joseph Sarto (who became later Saint Pius X) signed a petition in the beginning of the 20th century, done by the congregation of rites with the question Continuer à lire →